SAN FRANCISCO — November 12, 2026. One of the city's most contested waterfront housing projects has reached a major administrative milestone but may still face lengthy litigation. San Francisco planners approved the Marina Safeway redevelopment on November 6, allowing a proposal for 848 homes in towers of 22 and 18 stories with a replacement grocery store at 11–15 Marina Boulevard to advance toward demolition and construction permits. Neighbors who oppose the project have already sued the city, PG&E and developer Align Real Estate in federal court, arguing that contamination on the former industrial property demands more investigation. Planning approval is not proof that construction has begun or that a court has resolved the case.
What the city approved
The San Francisco Standard reported that a November 6 city approval letter advanced the proposal using California's Assembly Bill 2011, a streamlined ministerial process for eligible developments on commercial land. The ABC7 November 9 report says 86 of the 848 apartments would be set aside for lower-income households. Those units are part of the proposed plan; the coverage does not establish when they would become available for applications or at what rents.
Why environmental review is disputed
According to SFGATE's November 11 account, groups and residents filed a federal lawsuit in September alleging that the city permitted the streamlined approval without adequately investigating suspected contamination from historical industrial uses. A PG&E steam power plant formerly operated at this location, and petroleum contamination has been reported in soil and groundwater. Alleged unresolved contamination is not proof that existing shoppers or future tenants face a present exposure hazard. The San Francisco Chronicle reports that state regulators have said the currently known contamination does not present a current exposure risk.
Developer and city responses
Align says it will comply with applicable environmental testing requirements and has welcomed the approval as a step toward new housing and an updated store. City planners say additional assessment and any required cleanup can occur through permitting and before residences are occupied. The plaintiffs contend that required review should have taken place before the city's streamlined determination. These competing positions raise a legal and technical question that the pending litigation, underlying studies and any agency decisions will need to address.
How a major project avoided a typical public hearing
San Francisco Planning's August 2026 guidance on ministerial approval explains that eligible AB 2011 mixed-income projects are assessed against objective criteria and generally do not go through the discretionary hearing and CEQA procedures associated with ordinary projects. The developer relies on that framework; opponents challenge how it was applied to this property. It is inaccurate to say that bypassing a discretionary hearing automatically amounts to misconduct or that the plan is exempt from every environmental safeguard.
What neighborhood groups and city leaders want
Opponents have raised the height of the towers, coastal views, the replacement grocery's future and the extent of environmental testing. District 2 Supervisor Stephen Sherrill and Mayor Daniel Lurie have criticized the project's scale or its reliance on earlier zoning rules, according to Chronicle reporting. Align emphasizes housing supply and the larger replacement Safeway. A poll organized by one opposing neighborhood group suggests discontent among respondents, but its sampling method was not disclosed and cannot be generalized to every Marina resident.
EDITORIAL FOLLOW-UP — November 12, 2026: San Francisco News has sent an on-the-record request to the SF Planning media office asking for the November 6 determination, the project's environmental-testing and permitting requirements, the applicable affordable-housing restrictions and opportunities for further public input. A response has been requested and is not yet reported. The pending lawsuit and the allegation of inadequate review remain distinct from any final court findings.
Questions San Francisco News will follow
- Where can the public read the November 6 approval letter and all objective AB 2011 eligibility findings?
- Which site testing, remediation and agency sign-offs will be required before demolition, excavation or residential use?
- When will the original grocery close, and how will the neighborhood be served during construction?
- What are the legally binding affordability terms for the proposed 86 lower-income apartments?
- What is the next federal court date and which permit or land-use questions remain unresolved?
Next development: SFGATE reports that a federal judge is expected to address Align's motion to dismiss in February 2027; that is not a guarantee of the final case outcome. Align has not announced a construction start date. San Francisco News welcomes dated documents and responses from Planning, the company, plaintiffs and environmental regulators at california58com@gmail.com. Sources: SF Standard Nov. 8, SFGATE Nov. 11, ABC7 Nov. 9, and official SF Planning AB 2011 guidance.
Support San Francisco News
Choose how to support San Francisco News:
Credit / Debit Card via StripeChoose your contribution amount on the secure California58 Stripe checkout. One-time support for independent local journalism.
Continue with PayPal Continue with ZelleZelle payments go to Vitaly Ataev Troshin. Please verify the recipient in your bank before sending. Availability depends on your bank.
Optional reader support. When possible, add “San Francisco News” to the payment note. Contributions are not advertised as tax-deductible. Support does not influence editorial decisions.More from San Francisco News
- How to Find Russian-Speaking Tax Help in San Francisco for the 2027 Filing Season →
- San Francisco Port Flood and Earthquake Projects Could Be Exempted From Early Fiscal Feasibility Reviews →
- San Francisco Hotel Workers Could Gain Right to Sue Over Certain Cleaning and Disease-Prevention Violations →
- San Francisco Airport Surveillance Policy Faces First Reading Covering License Plate Readers and Parking Systems →
- San Francisco Board to Vote on $1.765 Million for Immigration Legal Defense and Community Response →
COMMUNITY
Comments
Join the California58 conversation. You must be signed in to comment.
Create a free California58 account or sign in with an available social provider.